Wow, nice info, thanks, Ill pass this onto my developer. Thanks again On Fri, 2003-09-19 at 16:25, Joseph Landman wrote: > Having written automated installation tools for IRIX (Autoinst, the > predecessor to Roboinst, used for a number of years), and looking at > things like SI and other imaging tools, I personally prefer the > non-image based solutions, as they do not introduce this new layer of > management you have to worry about (image management) and debug. > Imaging is great for some things (laptop loads, etc). > > FAI looks like they do some things right. It looks like they do not > have an automatic method of BOOTP mac address harvesting though. That > could be quite painful on a reasonable sized cluster. There are a > number of ways to handle that, including using File::Tail on the > /var/log/messages for your dhcp server. From this, you can have a > script automatically build your dhcpd.conf file, populate your > /etc/hosts, etc. > > Note: Autoinst booted IRIX into a diskless mode, handled all the disk > partitioning and file system formatting, package installation, etc. > Rules built in to it (much like the FAI classes) allowed for multiple > mixed hardware types with package/layout variations. Pissed the network > people off though... it was faster to use this than to do a fresh > install via CD. Imaging over the network was marginally faster to get > the image onto the disk, but then you had to do the post image > processing to make the machine unique, and sometimes (in those days) the > image transfer was not successful, so you had to do it again over poor > networks. The package method returned a code as to whether or not the > package install succeeded, so that inst could handle problems. All in > all the package method turned out to be significantly better in terms of > ease of use and reliability. > > Please let us know how it goes. > > On Fri, 2003-09-19 at 00:52, Nox wrote: > > We have begun to investigate FAI and Debian for our clustering > > solutions. > > > > I have always been partial to Debian, its my OS of choice, > > has been for yrs. > > > > So when I discovered the clustering tools, I was excited. > > (FAI, Fully Automated Install) > > > > Does anyone have experience with this? > > Pitfalls, things to watch for, > > success stories etc. > > > > from my perspective: > > > > Debian offers ease of use > > Updates are a snap (apt-get) --Including security > > Ability to be a very minimalist system > > Quick access to Biotech tools (bioperl as an example) > > > > We currently use debian as our Halted Firewall as well. > > > > Thanks in advance > > > > Nox > > GenMicro Systems > > > > _______________________________________________ > > Bioclusters maillist - Bioclusters@bioinformatics.org > > https://bioinformatics.org/mailman/listinfo/bioclusters